Gulliver | It’s not how far you go but how much you spend

One of America’s last distance-based frequent-flyer programmes ends

This is the summer that miles will officially stop having anything to do with miles

By A.W. WASHINGTON, DC

THIS is the summer that miles will officially stop having anything to do with miles. American Airlines was the last holdout among the big carriers in the United States in maintaining a frequent-flyer programme that rewarded customers for the distance they travelled. The formula was simple: fly a mile, get a mile. But all of American’s main rivals—from legacy carriers Delta and United to Southwest, JetBlue and Virgin America—have already made the switch to a system based on the amount people spend on flights, not the distance they travelled. On Monday, American announced that it would do the same.

When other carriers introduced such measures there was much gnashing of teeth among frequent flyers, who suspected a rouse to diddle them out of what they were due. Others suggested that it created a perverse incentive for business travellers to book the most expensive flights, rather than help their employers by looking for a bargain. But such concerns held little sway with American. In an e-mail to members of the AAdvantage programme, the country’s largest carrier explained that the change would give “our best customers access to our most exclusive benefits”. It follows a recent pattern of catering increasingly to well-heeled flyers, one that’s seen a growing divergence in amenities (and price) between coach and business class. American’s distance-based system may have been simple to understand and beneficial to travellers who secured low fares for long flights. But for customers who spend a lot on their journeys—particularly for business—and want to be rewarded, there was an incentive to fly with other airlines.

Under American’s new system, which is being brought in on August 1st, most travellers will earn five miles for every dollar they spend on flights. But elite status will confer substantial benefits. Customers with gold status will earn seven miles per dollar; those with platinum will gain eight miles; and those with executive platinum will receive 11 miles.

In its announcement, American posted a sample round-trip flight from Dallas to Heathrow, with a base fare of $1,436 and $458 in carrier-imposed fees. For that flight, travellers without elite status would earn 9,470 miles, while those with executive platinum status would get 20,834 miles—nearly enough for a free round-trip domestic flight.

To receive elite status, customers must meet two thresholds: a minimum number of miles earned and a minimum annual spending level, ranging from $3,000 for gold to $12,000 for executive platinum. For most, this is all purely theoretical. But for business travellers and other frequent flyers, American may have just become a more appealing option.

More from Gulliver

How much will Hong Kong's protests damage visitor numbers?

Tourism is a surprisingly resilient industry—but only if governments want it to be

Why Hong Kong’s airport was a good target for protesters

The streets of 19th-century Paris and the postmodern architecture of Hong Kong’s main terminal have much in common


Why trains are not always as green as they seem

The “flight-shame” movement encourages travellers to go by train instead of plane. But not all rail lines are environmentally friendly