United States | Six degrees and separation

Immigrants to America are better educated than ever before

Far from being low-skilled, half of all legal migrants have college degrees

|NEW YORK

JOSÉ ROMMEL UMANO, who is originally from the Philippines, moved to New York last autumn. He came on a family-reunification visa and joined his wife, who had been living in America for some time. This is a typical tale: America gives more weight to close family members when considering immigration applications than some other rich countries do. More surprising is that Mr Rommel Umano arrived with a master’s degree from the University of Tokyo and 20 years of experience as an architect in Japan. Yet this, it turns out, is typical too. Nearly half of all immigrants who arrived between 2011 and 2015 were college-educated. This is a level “unheard of” in America, says Jeanne Batalova, co-author of the paper containing the finding published by the Migration Policy Institute (MPI), a think-tank.

One of Donald Trump’s many executive orders instructed the Departments of Labour, Justice and Homeland Security to examine immigration rules. The president, whose hostility to illegal migrants is well-known, has also said that he would like to change the criteria for choosing legal ones, pointing to Canada or Australia as models for America to copy. In 1967 Canada became the first country to introduce a points system for immigration; Canada and Australia now both give priority to would-be migrants with degrees, work experience and fluent English (and, in Canada, French). Some of the president’s advisers think this more hard-headed system is better than America’s family-centred approach. The doomed immigration bill from 2013 that died in the House of Representatives also reflected widespread enthusiasm for a points-based system.

Two things ought to temper this enthusiasm. First, Canada and Australia have concluded that pure points systems do not work well. A surprisingly high share of the people admitted this way ended up unemployed. Both countries have since changed their immigration criteria so that applicants who have job offers in their pockets may jump the queue. Second, migrants who move to America to join family members have become much better educated.

Of the more than 1m new green-card holders (or permanent residents) in 2015, the most recent year with numbers available, almost half were immediate relatives of citizens. A further 20% entered through preferences given to other family members. That left just 14% who were sponsored by companies, about the same share who first entered the country as refugees or asylum-seekers (a further 5% were lottery winners). Despite this bias towards families, the share of immigrants who arrived with degrees has risen from 27%, for those who arrived between and 1986 and 1990, to almost half now.

America is not the only rich country to have seen such an increase. According to the OECD (a club of mostly wealthy countries), the number of college-educated migrants heading to member countries grew by 70% between 2001 and 2011. Recent migrants to America are as likely to be highly educated as those who move to Europe are. They still lag some way behind Australia and Canada, though.

The result is that America has switched from importing people who are, on average, less educated than the natives to people who are better schooled. Most states gained in college-educated immigrant populations between 2010 and 2015 (see map). Immigrants were more educated than Americans in 26 states. “This shift has gone unnoticed by the broader population and policymakers,” says Ms Batalova of the MPI. Many people have an outdated notion of who immigrants are, conflating them with the undocumented. The number of undocumented migrants has been falling, but even they are more likely to have a degree these days: the MPI reckons that a fifth of graduate immigrants are undocumented. Nearly a third of refugees have at least one degree.

One difficulty even educated migrants face on arrival is that employers do not always recognise foreign degrees and experience abroad. Antiquated licensing requirements and regulations also hurt. Upwardly Global, a charity which helps skilled immigrants translate their CVs into American, cites the example of a former Médecins Sans Frontières doctor from Botswana who worked as a waiter until he got help to navigate the system. As for Mr Rommel Umano, despite his years as an architect and two degrees, he had a hard time getting work in his profession in America. Needing money, he took a job loading boxes in a New Jersey warehouse two hours away from his home in the Bronx. The charity polished his CV and put him through mock interviews and in touch with his current employer, a construction firm. There, he says the work is pretty similar to what he was doing in Japan.

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline "Six degrees and separation"

Terror and the internet

From the June 10th 2017 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

Do undocumented immigrants have the right to own guns?

A federal court in Chicago decides that some do. Republicans are outraged

Chicago wants to stop Glock pistols being turned into machineguns

The city is suing the manufacturer


Georgia’s black Republicans have a battle plan for 2024

Joe Biden will have to work harder to win the state’s black voters this year