Briefing | Innovation pessimism

Has the ideas machine broken down?

The idea that innovation and new technology have stopped driving growth is getting increasing attention. But it is not well founded

BOOM times are back in Silicon Valley. Office parks along Highway 101 are once again adorned with the insignia of hopeful start-ups. Rents are soaring, as is the demand for fancy vacation homes in resort towns like Lake Tahoe, a sign of fortunes being amassed. The Bay Area was the birthplace of the semiconductor industry and the computer and internet companies that have grown up in its wake. Its wizards provided many of the marvels that make the world feel futuristic, from touch-screen phones to the instantaneous searching of great libraries to the power to pilot a drone thousands of miles away. The revival in its business activity since 2010 suggests progress is motoring on.

So it may come as a surprise that some in Silicon Valley think the place is stagnant, and that the rate of innovation has been slackening for decades. Peter Thiel, a founder of PayPal, an internet payment company, and the first outside investor in Facebook, a social network, says that innovation in America is “somewhere between dire straits and dead”. Engineers in all sorts of areas share similar feelings of disappointment. And a small but growing group of economists reckon the economic impact of the innovations of today may pale in comparison with those of the past.

This article appeared in the Briefing section of the print edition under the headline "Has the ideas machine broken down?"

The great innovation debate

From the January 12th 2013 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Briefing

America’s $61bn aid package buys Ukraine time

It must use it wisely

America is uniquely ill-suited to handle a falling population

Which is a worry, because much of it is already shrinking


Homeowners face a $25trn bill from climate change

Property, the world’s biggest asset class, is also its most vulnerable