Gulliver | Banning babies in first class

Malaysia Airlines goes infant-free on the A380, too

Finally, some peace and quiet?

By N.B. | SAN FRANCISCO

MALAYSIA AIRLINES, which previously banned infants from first-class cabins on its 747-400s, will do the same on its newer Airbus A380s, its chief exeutive, Tengku Azmil Aziz told Australian Business Traveller on Sunday via Twitter. Every business traveller knows that a crying infant can ruin what otherwise might be a fairly restful night in first or business class. But sometimes new parents need to fly, too. Should they and their offspring really be relegated to the back of the plane for the greater good?

It's a tough question. I don't begrudge Malaysia Airlines its business decision, but I hope that at least some of its competitors continue to allow babies up front. New parents who want to fly in first class should at least have the option of choosing an airline that is willing to accommodate them. Currently, infants aren't a particularly common sight in premium cabins. But it would be too bad if there comes a day when they are universally banned.

Unfortunately for new parents, airlines' profit margins are heavily reliant on business travellers, and people travelling for business are much less likely to have babies with them. So if you run an airline that is trying to attract more business travellers (and press attention), banning babies might seem like a smart play. If Mr Aziz's ploy proves to be successful, and attracts more premium travellers to his airline, it could easily spread widely. (The rule might, however, run into trouble in jurisdictions that want to prohibit discrimination against new parents or their babies.)

Malaysia Airlines is sure to get a lot of publicity (positive and negative) from this decision, and perhaps that was the main goal. But it's worth noting that crying babies aren't the only thing that can make a flight uncomfortable. (Also, they don't always cry—I was on a flight last week from New York to San Francisco and the infant behind me didn't make a peep the whole way, even though it was bumpy.) Although Mr Aziz's company may lead the world in infant-free first class, it also crams more people (508) into its A380 configuration than any other airline except Lufthansa and Air France. And while noise-cancelling headphones can allow you to sleep through the loudest of tantrums, they can't give you more leg room.

More from Gulliver

How much will Hong Kong's protests damage visitor numbers?

Tourism is a surprisingly resilient industry—but only if governments want it to be

Why Hong Kong’s airport was a good target for protesters

The streets of 19th-century Paris and the postmodern architecture of Hong Kong’s main terminal have much in common


Why trains are not always as green as they seem

The “flight-shame” movement encourages travellers to go by train instead of plane. But not all rail lines are environmentally friendly