Europe | Jupiter meets Mercury

Emmanuel Macron tries to win over Donald Trump on Iran

France’s president has little in common with America’s, but somehow they get along

Who's the leader?
|PARIS
Listen to this story.
Enjoy more audio and podcasts on iOS or Android.

THE speech was a knock-out, Congressmen swooned, and he made a forceful pitch to be the leader of the liberal world order. But will any of that matter unless Emmanuel Macron can change Donald Trump? The young French president turned up in Washington this week for his state visit keen to make something of the oddly close link he has forged with his American counterpart. Top of his list was an effort to persuade the American leader not to walk away from the Iran nuclear agreement. Even better, though considerably less likely, would be to get America to rejoin the Paris climate-change process.

Mr Trump has threatened to quit the Iran deal on May 12th, and may still do so. Yet, for the first time, the American president hinted this week that he might be interested in a European idea, promoted by the French president, of brokering an add-on deal to cover wider American concerns about Iran. If this can keep Mr Trump on board, it would indeed be a big diplomatic coup for Mr Macron, though he acknowledges that the chances are slim.

The side deal proposed by the Europeans, though very far from accepted by Iran, would cover Iran’s ballistic missile programme and its regional interference, as well as extend beyond 2025 Iran’s commitment to curb its nuclear activities. Though Mr Trump this week called the existing deal “insane” and “ridiculous”, he also hinted that there was some common ground between them. “I think,” said Mr Trump, “we will have a great shot at doing a much bigger, maybe, deal.”

Given the American president’s volatility and his team’s hostility to any compromise over Iran, this is a big gamble for Mr Macron. Indeed, since he was elected a year ago, he has invested heavily in trying to use his warm relationship with the American leader to win him round, on matters from climate to trade, tolerating strange moments of public humiliation in the process. At one point in the Oval Office this week, the American president flicked what he called “dandruff” from Mr Macron’s collar, declaring: “We have to make him perfect.” At another, he appeared to tug Mr Macron along like a dog.

The pair make a decidedly odd couple. It is hard to imagine two Western leaders with more contrasting worldviews. The host, a brash former reality-television star was elected on a promise to shut borders and spurn multilateralism. The guest, a cerebral philosophy graduate, won power by rejecting nationalism and praising Europe and the liberal world order. Yet the pair seem to have found a certain respect for each other, ever since Mr Macron gave Mr Trump a knuckle-crunching handshake when they first met a year ago. Each is a political outsider—a “maverick”, in Mr Macron’s words—who won power against the odds. For Mr Macron, the summit was a chance to show the world that France still counts. For Mr Trump, it is gratifying to have a clever, dynamic young leader flatteringly wanting to be his friend. Some call Mr Macron the “Trump whisperer”.

By staking so much on the Iran deal, Mr Macron has put his credibility as an emerging European leader on the line. He certainly does not seek to align himself unconditionally with Mr Trump, although France took part in—and indeed urged—recent air strikes with America and Britain against Syrian chemical-weapons facilities. Rather, the French president’s ambition is, at best, to encourage the American leader to use his country’s influence in a more benign way and at least to keep him from inflicting too much damage. His impassioned speech, in English, to a joint sitting of Congress, appealing for multi-lateralism and liberal values, won him a standing ovation.

So far, the French seem happy to let Mr Macron make a go of this relationship. They generally prefer their leaders to project the country’s independence, as did de Gaulle, and pillory those who cosy up to Americans, as Nicolas Sarkozy did to George W. Bush. As Mr Macron prepares to mark the first anniversary of his election on May 7th, he is not popular at home. Yet most people like the way he has changed the country’s image abroad. His talk of grandeur and prestige goes down well, and the prospect of France acting as Europe’s preferred leader in Washington seems to make up for popular distaste for Mr Trump.

At some point, however, there will be domestic pressure on Mr Macron to show something in return for all this Trump-flattery. He has on occasion exaggerated his influence over his American counterpart. But he also knows that their differences are great and, at times, insurmountable. “My view…is that he will get rid of this deal on his own, for domestic reasons”, Mr Macron said as he left. If he cannot secure tangible returns for his efforts, he will run the risk of looking naive, or foolish, or both.

This article appeared in the Europe section of the print edition under the headline "Jupiter meets Mercury"

Within reach: Universal health care, worldwide

From the April 28th 2018 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Europe

The tiny republic of San Marino is alarmingly friendly to Russia

Intelligence sources fear the country, surrounded by Italy, is a haven for spies

Two years of war have impoverished many Ukrainians

The elderly, the displaced and the disabled are the worst affected


Ukraine is ignoring US warnings to end drone operations inside Russia

Its superdrones can reach targets as far away as Siberia