Leaders | A clarion call

Hong Kong’s elections were a rebuke to its government

The chief executive, Carrie Lam, and her backers in Beijing must draw the right lesson

DISTRICT ELECTIONS in Hong Kong are normally about rat control and bus routes. The polls on November 24th were a vote on Hong Kong’s future as a liberal Chinese enclave. The question, in effect, was whether ordinary people support the government and its backers in Beijing in their illiberal methods. The answer was a resounding no. The turnout, of over 70%, was higher than any recorded in any kind of election in Hong Kong in which the public has a say (see article). Pro-democracy politicians almost swept the board.

For Hong Kong’s leaders and China’s Communist Party, this is a rebuke—compounded three days later when President Donald Trump signed into law a bill that supports Hong Kong’s democracy. Irked by months of protests, but unwilling to use troops to crush the demonstrators, they had hoped ordinary Hong Kongers would turn against the black-clad pro-democracy protesters. The election result destroys that dream. The “silent majority” turns out to back the protesters’ cause, despite the violent tactics of some.

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline "A clarion call"

Inequality illusions

From the November 28th 2019 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Leaders

How to pacify the world’s most violent region

The iron-fist approach will not solve Latin America’s gang-violence problem

Why South Africans are fed up after 30 years of democracy

After a bright start the ANC has proved incapable of governing for the whole country


How disinformation works—and how to counter it

More co-ordination is needed, and better access to data