Leaders | Voting reform

American democracy’s built-in bias towards rural Republicans

Its elections no longer convert the popular will into control of government

EVERY system for converting votes into power has its flaws. Britain suffers from an over-mighty executive; Italy from chronically weak government; Israel from small, domineering factions. America, however, is plagued by the only democratic vice more troubling than the tyranny of the majority: tyranny of the minority.

This has come about because of a growing division between rural and urban voters. The electoral system the Founders devised, and which their successors elaborated, gives rural voters more clout than urban ones. When the parties stood for both city and country that bias affected them both. But the Republican Party has become disproportionately rural and the Democratic Party disproportionately urban. That means a red vote is worth more than a blue one.

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline "American democracy’s built-in bias"

American democracy’s built-in bias

From the July 14th 2018 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Leaders

What companies can expect if Labour wins Britain’s election

The party that aspires to lead the country is courting business

Threats to Europe’s economy are mounting. Finance can help fortify it

Time to press ahead with banking and capital-market reforms


The liberal international order is slowly coming apart

Its collapse could be sudden and irreversible