Culture | Johnson

Why you have an accent in a foreign language

It is because pronunciation, stress and rhythm are rarely taught well

OPEN A TEXTBOOK for a foreign language, and one of the first things you see is an alphabet, enumerating the letters used in the writing system and the sounds they represent. This is obviously crucial for unfamiliar systems, say those of Greek or Russian. But even for languages that rely on the Latin alphabet, the guide will explain how diacritics such as accent marks change a letter’s pronunciation, and quirks such as the -ch- in German or -gl- in Italian. (The first often sounds like the ch in Scottish loch, the second like the -ll- in million.)

And with that, it’s off to master greetings, vocabulary and so on, with little further thought for pronunciation. This is a shame. There is much more to learning a foreign accent than the sounds that the letters on the page represent. To begin with, the rough equivalents given in English are often quite rough indeed. In French, the p in Paris sounds rather different from the p in English, a contrast often neglected in textbooks: the French version lacks the strong puff of air of the English one. (Hold your palm in front of your mouth and say “Paris” in English. Then try making the p without the puff, and you’ll get the French kind.)

This article appeared in the Culture section of the print edition under the headline "Stress tests"

The energy shock

From the October 14th 2021 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Culture

The hit series “Bridgerton” has set off a string-quartet boom

It is a surprising example of how popular culture can shape consumer habits

What if calling someone stupid was a crime?

Lionel Shriver imagines cancel culture going to even greater extremes


Fury vs Usyk is the biggest fight this century

Boxing’s prioritisation of money over competition is hurting the sport