Can too many brainy people be a dangerous thing?
Some academics argue that unhappy elites lead to political instability
TEN YEARS ago Peter Turchin, a scientist at the University of Connecticut, made a startling prediction in Nature. “The next decade is likely to be a period of growing instability in the United States and western Europe,” he asserted, pointing in part to the “overproduction of young graduates with advanced degrees”. The subsequent surge in populism in Europe, the unexpected votes in 2016 for Brexit and then for President Donald Trump in America, and a wave of protests from the gilets jaunes to Black Lives Matter, has made Mr Turchin something of a celebrity in certain circles, and has piqued economists’ interest in the discipline of “cliodynamics”, which uses maths to model historical change. Mr Turchin’s emphasis on the “overproduction of elites” raises uncomfortable questions, but also offers useful policy lessons.
As far back as ancient Rome and imperial China, Mr Turchin shows, societies have veered from periods of political stability to instability, often at intervals of about 50 years. Consider America. Every pundit knows that Congress has become gridlocked, with Democrats and Republicans unwilling to compromise with each other. Fewer know that it was also highly polarised around 1900, before becoming more co-operative in the mid-20th century.
This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline "Graduates of the world, unite!"
Finance & economics October 24th 2020
- Wall Street will soon have to take millennial investors seriously
- Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala is the favourite to lead the WTO
- The front-runner for Joe Biden’s Treasury boss has a mighty CV
- Price gouging: a cautionary tale
- Who decides what counts as an emerging market?
- How Berlin has become a centre for European venture capital
- Can too many brainy people be a dangerous thing?
- Wanted: a new writer to cover finance
More from Finance and economics
What campus protesters get wrong about divestment
Will withdrawing money hurt Israel?
Hedge funds make billions as India’s options market goes ballistic
The country’s retail investors are doing less well
Russia’s gas business will never recover from the war in Ukraine
Hopes of a Chinese rescue look increasingly vain